Three Great Nights in July

GoodEveningNYC_DVDAugust 15, 1965 was a historic date in the annals of rock and roll. The Beatles played in front of 55,600 frenzied “Beatlemaniacs” in the fist rock show at a major stadium. Playing 12 songs in 30 minutes, the four lads from Liverpool were barely heard by the screaming fans and by each other. The Beatles stage monitors were not up to today’s standards, so the band played by heart and instinct in order to put on a stellar show. The concert was the template for every other future record-breaking stadium show (“Led Zeppelin”-Tampa Stadium) and mega-festivals like Woodstock, The Isle of Wight Festival, California Jam and Texas Jam to name a few. It also showed that rock and roll was here to stay. As it so often happens in life, things come full circle. On July 17,18 and 21 2009, Paul McCartney returned to the scene of past glory( a few hundred yards away) to play in front of 109,397 fans over three nights at the new home of the Mets, Citi Field, recapturing past glory with a dynamic, well performed concert extravaganza.

“Good Evening New York City,” a new 33 song + DVD package is must for McCartney fans who are Beatle fanatics, embrace his solo career with “Wings” and after and just want to hear a polished, professional and talented legend do what he does best, perform at a high level and never disappoint. The sixty-seven year old legend, who had celebrated that birthday a month earlier, sang in most of the original keys that the songs were written in, which is a challenging undertaking considering how long ago some Beatles classics like, “Drive My Car” (a great show opener), “Got to Get You Into My Life,” “Eleanor Rigby,” “Day Tripper,” “Paperback Writer” and “I Saw Her Standing There” (featuring guest Billy Joel) were conceived. His bass playing and piano work are also first-rate and underscore the fact that he is still an underrated musician despite his iconic status.

Lest you think this was only a Beatles greatest hits tour, McCartney treated the audience to solo material like “Only Mama Knows” and “Dance Tonight” from the introspective “Memory Almost Full” release and the underappreciated “Sing the Changes” and “Highway” from 2008’s “Fireman” album “Electric Arguments.” McCartney also goes back to his “Wings” days and rocks the assembled throng with scorching guitar on “Let Me Roll It,” a spot on rendition of the title track, “Band on the Run” and tender lilting vocal styling on “My Love,” a love ode to his late wife Linda from 1973’s “Red Rose Speedway.” One song that is worth the price of this package is “Live and Let Die,” McCartney’s James Bond theme(1973) which is presented in an epic performance.Two other strong solo performances are two tracks from 1997’s “Flaming Pie,” the title track, and “Calico Skies.”

A particular touching aspect of the show is McCartney paying homage to his deceased former band mates George Harrison (Disc 1) and John Lennon (Disc 2). He sings “Something,” a Beatles standard that was written and sung by Harrison on “Abbey Road.” A unique aspect of this performance is McCartney utilizing a ukulele and his voice alone as he did on the “Concert for George” tribute concert. It is a stripped down raw, emotional high point of the show and a fitting gesture. It eventually morphs into a band version with a beautiful guitar solo that does justice to Harrison’s on the original piece. McCartney also sings the Beatles “A Day in the Life” and Lennon’s “Give Peace a Chance” together, thus paying tribute to Lennon, singing his verse on the former and getting the crowd involved in a sing-along with the Lennon plea for peace from his solo career on the latter.

Emotion aside, McCartney’s band rocks, pure and simple. The opening track of disc two, “Back in the U.S.S.R.” is an example of rock brilliance and features an “incendiary” guitar solo by Rusty Anderson. It is followed up by “I’m Down” which he performed on that aforementioned magical night in 1965. “I’ve Got a Feeling,” from 1970’s “Let it Be” is done fantastically with Paul’s band mate filling in admirably on Lennon’s parts. It must be underscored that McCartney’s band, which consists of Paul “Wix” Wicken (key boards), Brian Ray (bass guitar), Rusty Anderson (guitar-mentioned above) and the powerful Abe Laboriel Jr. (drums), are a great band and not just an undistinguished backing band. Wicken’s keyboard work along with strings and horn simulation is wondrous. Some songs that were never performed by the Beatles on stage because they stopped touring in 1966 are reproduced brilliantly on this release.

McCartney brings down the house and fills the crowd with emotion on “Let It Be,” “Yesterday,” “Hey Jude” and brings the show to a “fiery” crescendo with “Helter Skelter,” “Get Back” and the reprise of “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” and “The End”, the last thing the Beatles ever put on record( remember those?). The show never lets up and was not just a wink at the past, but rather an affirmation of McCartney’s talent and dedication to his craft to this day.

If that is not enough to titillate you, the third disc is a DVD of the whole show filmed masterfully with incredible sound. A nice touch is camera shots of the enthusiastic crowd of all ages that is not done gratuitously that captures the historic significance of the concerts and the emotion and enthusiasm of the crowd that witnessed a landmark moment in rock history. The tracks on the CD and DVD are culled from performances during the three-night run. There will be a deluxe set released (2CD’s+2DVD’s) which will feature expanded packaging and a bonus DVD which features McCartney’s July 15, 2009 performance on the David Letterman show in which McCartney played on the marquee of the Ed Sullivan Theater (where the Beatles played Sullivan’s show many moons ago). This impromptu appearance caused traffic and pedestrian logjams in the area.The short set by McCartney was aired on Letterman’s show. This package includes bonus tracks that were not shown on the broadcast.

As McCartney himself states, “It was three great nights for me and the band personally.It was very exciting to be back opening a new stadium on the site of the old Shea Stadium where we played 44 years previously. Even more exciting because this time round you could hear us!” It was a concert for the ages and if you pick up the standard or deluxe editions, you will not believe your eyes and ears. This humble writer played it at a party and received numerous requests from attendees to tell me where I purchased it. If you are thinking of a gift that will be much appreciated this upcoming holiday season for classic rock and non-classic rock fans alike, you cannot go wrong with Paul McCartney’s “Good Evening New York City.”

About Steve Janowsky 88 Articles
Steve Janowsky is a former co-host of the Rocktologists theme based classic rock show radio show on WKRB 90.3 fm, which was voted the best classic rock podcast in the country by Dave White of Some of the interview guests on the show were Simon Kirke ( Free and Bad Company), Carl Palmer (ELP), Vince Martell (Vanilla Fudge), Randy Jackson (Zebra) and Frank Marino of Mahogany Rush. Janowsky is also an English and Journalism instructor at Kingsborough Community College in Brooklyn, NY and is an avid guitar player and songwriter.


  1. Somehow I missed this one when it was first posted. One thing about McCar5tney – even though he’s turned into an “oldies” act (IMHO), he puts 110% of his energy into his live shows and never comes across as stale. Remarkable for someone pushing 70.

Leave a Reply